It would seem that New Haven’s Aramark-hating unions got their way, but they’re still complaining. School cafeteria workers and custodians made a big enough stink about Aramark, the company managing both school food service and school maintenance, that the Board of Education will put the company’s contract out to bid this spring.
But that’s not good enough. School custodians are now trashing Aramark about the dumpsters they have to use. The hulking, covered blue bins are “bear proof,” which makes them difficult to use, custodians say. And even if it wasn’t Aramark’s decision to buy and use the bear-proof bins—which have made work more onerous for the custodians—it happened on their watch. This week, the custodian’s union, Local 287 of AFSCME Council 4, is launching a campaign with 10 billboards that read, “Hey Aramark! There’s No Bears in New Haven Schools.” The billboard campaign is costing the union $6,150.
The union wants city taxpayers to believe that contracting out maintenance and food service to outside companies is a waste of tax dollars. They’ll be spending the next few weeks highlighting mismanagement in city schools, starting with the bear-proof dumpsters.
Aside from being redundant—the schools have fulfilled custodians’ demand to rebid Aramark’s contract—the campaign may be misdirected. Will Clark, the school’s finance chief operating officer, says it wasn’t Aramark’s decision to buy these dumpsters—it was the city’s.
Aramark’s spokeswoman, Kristine Grow, says, “Any characterization of Aramark’s playing a role in this is totally wrong. That’s not a decision that we make. That’s left up to the Board of Education.” Grow claims the union is campaigning against Aramark simply to grow membership.
Clark says the city Public Works Department had been using the bear-proof dumpsters and suggested the schools use them also to ward off illegal dumping.
But city spokeswoman Jessica Mayorga says the Board of Ed and Aramark together came up with the idea to buy the dumpsters and the truck needed to empty them and haul off the trash. The city and the Board of Ed are preparing to buy a third truck—we now have more schools, more trash and more need—at a cost of $205,000.
Whoever made the decision, the union is going to pin it on Aramark.
Everyone seems to agree that bears aren’t common in New Haven, but illegal dumping is and bear-proof dumpsters are supposed to deter that practice. “Bear-proof” means the bins are covered, says Clark, which also helps with odor control. “It avoids public dumping for health and safety issues. It keeps the area clean and safe as well.” But the union says the lids’ locks don’t work.
Local 287 president Rob Montouri heard Clark’s line when the dumpsters were first brought into the schools. “They told us they’d be easier to handle and the schools would be cleaner. There’d be no more milk leaking,” he says.
That hasn’t happened. “Those dumpsters leaked from day one,” says Montouri. The lids are heavy and have fallen on employees, causing injuries. And, Montouri says, some dumpsters are missing their lids, creating trash overflows, and negating the primary reasons for buying the bins: cleanliness and odor control.
That’s why the custodians are upset: They say the bins are difficult to empty, and they cause a mess.
Cherese Chambers, who lives directly across the street from the blue dumpsters at Lincoln Basset School in Newhallville sees and smells the trash all the time. “It stinks like sour milk,” she says. “They go a week without picking up the trash and I have to call and call and call to make a complaint.” When the trash is picked up, Chambers says the area is messy. “I’ve seen lots of skunks and last week I saw what I thought was a big rat.”
Still no bears, though.
byagla@newhavenadvocate.com